Brussels Notebook: Politicians will remain on Santa’s ​naughty list in 2026

​Christmas is when people end up on Santa's nice or naughty list.

​This is based on performance over the year and for farmers one group was firmly on the naughty list.

A banner on display during the protest. Picture: Farmers for Actionplaceholder image
A banner on display during the protest. Picture: Farmers for Action

Despite a pre-Christmas gesture on inheritance tax, that group is made up of politicians, national and devolved. Regardless of party they simply do not get agriculture. They fail, through their policies, to see its potential; they instead heap upon it unproven net zero policies and urban-focussed biodiversity plans less effective than if countryside management were left to those who for generations have understood it best. Give farmers the right incentives and support and they will deliver more for both those core policies than an army of politicians and civil servants. That would flow from making environmental gains a by-product of efficient food production. This would also benefit the economy and the health of the nation.

Instead we get from politicians regulations heaped on regulations, and for that reason alone the naughty list is where they will remain in 2026. In a pre-Christmas search for approbation the government in London revealed new animal welfare regulations in England.

Protestplaceholder image
Protest

This is a motherhood and apple pie political issue, with which few would fundamentally disagree.

Improving animal welfare standards is in everyone's interest, in that welfare drives productivity in farming and gives farmers a selling point with consumers.

However it is over this selling point, in marketing speak USP, that the big policy flaw emerges. The NFU in England was quick to point this out and hopefully its views will be heard.

The flaw is that higher standards at home, worthy as they may be, are not matched by controls on imports to ensure they meet the same standard. This is an age old problem, underlined by products like Brazilian beef, poultry from the Far East and, thanks to the government and EU's supine trade deals to ward off Trump tariff threats, US imports too.

This is not just about products meeting basic hygiene standards under UK or EU legislation. It has to go further and take on board wider areas, from animal welfare and farm standards through how workers are treated in processing plants to the climate implication of shipping products half way around the world to drive down prices on supermarket shelves.

Politicians wrapping themselves in a cloak of moral superiority over animal welfare or climate change legislation must be forced off their moral high ground to explain their hypocrisy over this issue.

If this does not happen, farming will again be victim to the old adage of politicians using agriculture in a bid to 'fool all of the people, all of the time'. For years, with tougher controls on agriculture, we have been exporting a problem.

Out of sight, out of mind is the political philosophy in play. Questionable techniques are practised overseas, while farmers at home struggle on an uneven playing field. If climate change mitigation is the aim, this is a global concept and nothing is achieved; indeed given lax controls the situation is to make matters worse by penalising farmers here.

Before Brexit this applied in both the UK and EU and that has not changed. If anything the EU is going further and faster in its efforts to make things a bit more fair for farmers. In the UK the response has been another wasted Brexit opportunity.

The UK could ignore others and introduce rules that demand imports meet exactly the same standards as food produced at home. This would deliver genuine gains in the areas politicians are pursuing and allow them to lay genuine claim to the moral high ground. This would, however, mean explaining some less than palatable facts of economic life to consumers.

Those are that if you want high standards they come with costs attached; that means a willingness to pay slightly more for food, which will have higher credentials and be better in every aspect of quality.

If consumers and not just the middle class that make a lot of noise over these issues say no to that outcome, politicians need to get that message and accept they have no mandate for change. As an issue, this goes well beyond animal welfare changes in the headlines now to the green dogma being imposed on post-Brexit farming.

If politicians then persist with their policies the hypocrisy that is their hallmark will be laid bare for all to see.

News you can trust since 1963
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice