Keir Starmer has learned ‘all political careers end in failure’

The one time Ulster Unionist MP for South Down, Enoch Powell, once said “all political careers end in failure”. Few indeed do not follow that road.

This week, on the same day, two political careers came to an end for very different reasons. Convicted child abuser, Jeffrey Donaldson, was branded “vile and manipulative” by the party he once led.

On the same day Keir Starmer won sympathy for his dignity when he announced his resignation as prime minister and leader of the Labour party. A decent and honourable man, Starmer fell victim to his own political weakness. Ironically one reason was that he delivered such a massive Labour majority just two years ago. This allowed backbenchers to challenge difficult decisions, while in contrast a party has to work together if it is to survive in government with a tight majority. Starmer’s career in British politics may be over, but it will be no surprise if he ultimately returns to a global or European role, having ended up more successful and popular in arenas far removed from domestic politics. The assumption now is that Andy Burnham will take his party through to the next general election, but events have confirmed the lack of certainty in UK politics. Two years ago next month that same assumption applied to the then newly elected Starmer. That there is a need to change the approach to agriculture is beyond question. But there is less certainty that Burnham, with his urban political credentials, is the person to bring about change. Rachel Reeves remains a deeply unpopular Chancellor with farmers and she is set on course for a cabinet demotion. Hopefully that is not a sign Burnham will break his commitment to maintaining financial discipline. UK borrowing is already out of control and cuts rather than more spending are needed. Observers say Burnham is a shrewd political operator, but that one flaw is he likes to tell people what they want to hear. That is not an asset for a prime minister that needs to take tough decisions to boost defence spending. This is why his comment that the government needs to “look again” at inheritance tax on family farms needs to be greeted with scepticism rather than euphoria. The case for doing what he says is clear, as is the mechanism to ease pressure on family farms, while discouraging the use of agricultural property relief by the super-rich to avoid tax. The way is to increase the tax threshold to five million and take out reliefs beyond that. He could sell this as fairness and with Reeves gone there would be no U-turn by a new Chancellor. The farming lobby now has a case to press, but the list of those seeking the ear of a new prime minister will be long, with farming a long way down. What farming really needs is a root and branch review of policy around food security. We have seen in recent months how vulnerable food prices and security are to global shocks, but as that situation eases we will fail to learn lessons and instead return to business as usual. The usual is about a long term decline of productive agriculture and food production in what is not even a managed process. Instead we have an urban view of the countryside dominating Westminster politics and Burnham is as urban as it is possible to be. Whether there will be even the faint hope of radical change depends on two key decisions. Will Burnham break the Starmer and indeed Conservative track record by finally appointing a DEFRA minister capable to radical thinking on farming and the countryside; and will we move away from the present costly, unpopular commitment to net zero. I suspect those will be early disappointments for agriculture. Starmer secured the UK new respect in Europe and was shaping up for a new relationship with the EU that would be a real point of difference with Reform. That and standing up to Trump were probably his best moments, but they did not translate into admiration in domestic politics. It will be interesting to see what relations Burnham forges with the EU, given that he represents one of the most pro-Brexit constituencies in England. Agriculture needs a stable and strong relationship with our biggest export market; it liked the Starmer direction of travel. Now with a new prime minister we will have to wait to see if Burnham will risk unpopularity with those who swept him to Westminster and power by sticking with Starmer’s approach to Europe.

News you can trust since 1963
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice