Vote of no confidence demonstrates ‘depth of crisis engulfing DAERA’
DUP Deputy Leader Michelle McIlveen has said the Ulster Farmers’ Union vote of no confidence in DAERA’s leadership demonstrates the “urgent need to rebuild trust between the Department and the farming community”.
The Strangford MLA said: “The UFU vote is a very serious development and we understand why farmers have reached this point. It should be a wake-up call for the Minister and the senior leadership of DAERA. Monday’s Agriculture Committee meeting provided important information about the Fivemiletown cattle cull, but also demonstrated how many significant questions remain unanswered.
“Crucially, DAERA confirmed that destruction of the cattle was not inevitable under the court order. The Department had discretion over the manner of disposal.
“We therefore need to establish who decided that shooting the cattle was the only viable option, when that decision was made, what alternatives were considered and why they were rejected.”


Ms McIlveen continued: “Questions also remain about the urgency with which DAERA acted and the legal interpretation of the word ‘immediate’ in the court order. When my colleague Tom Buchanan asked for the specific statutory provision requiring disposal by a particular date, none was identified.
“There are also unanswered questions about the firearms operation, including how many rounds were fired and where they ended up. DAERA was also unable to confirm or rule out whether the wound subsequently discovered on a calf had been caused by a shot.
“There must equally be confidence in the independence of the review. I have asked the Minister to establish whether Dr Martin Blake, during his tenure as Chief Veterinary Officer in the Republic of Ireland, commissioned DAERA’s Humane Slaughter Team to undertake similar operations. If so, there is an obvious question about a potential conflict of interest which must be addressed.
“None of this minimises the serious animal welfare offences which led to the court order. The question is how DAERA subsequently exercised the discretion available to it.”
The DUP Deputy Leader concluded: “We must establish the facts and DAERA must answer the outstanding questions to ensure accountability where mistakes were made. Farmers are expected to meet exacting standards of accountability. They are entitled to expect the same from DAERA. Rebuilding that trust must start with listening and honest answers.”
TUV Leader Jim Allister MP said the UFU reaffirming its vote of no confidence in Andrew Muir and extending it to DAERA’s most senior officials demonstrates the “depth of the crisis engulfing the Department”.
“The farming community has reached the same inescapable conclusion which I expressed earlier this week: a desktop review, operating under terms of reference written by the Department and without power to compel witnesses or demand documents, cannot command public confidence,” Mr Allister stated.
“Independence is not secured merely by appointing an outsider to conduct a process which DAERA itself has designed and confined. The Department cannot be permitted to mark its own homework over an operation for which it was responsible.
“The UFU’s call for the immediate resignations of the Minister, Permanent Secretary and Chief Veterinary Officer underscores how serious this situation is for the Department. It cannot simply be dismissed or ridden out by Andrew Muir.”
The North Antrim MP added: “Andrew Muir should stop portraying himself as the victim, face up to the consequences of his Department’s actions at Fivemiletown and resign.”