McIlveen: Sinn Fein ANC Bill is unfunded, unfair and offers false hope to farmers

DUP Deputy Leader and Agriculture Spokesperson Michelle McIlveen MLA has said the party will oppose the Areas with Natural Constraints (Payments) Bill at Second Stage next week, warning that it is badly drafted, unsupported by the evidence and would unfairly reduce support for other farm businesses.

Michelle McIlveen MLA said: “Sinn Fein’s ANC Bill is being presented as a solution for farmers in disadvantaged areas, but the reality is very different. It is unfunded, poorly drafted and offers false hope to those it claims to help.

"When the now First Minister was DAERA Minister, she introduced the ANC scheme against official advice. Even when she later extended those payments, she did not do so permanently because the business case did not support it. That should tell its own story.

"It is also important to remember that the 2018 scheme was brought forward during my time in office. It amended the earlier O’Neill scheme and was always regarded as a transition scheme, essentially bringing that arrangement to an end rather than creating a permanent entitlement,” added Ms McIlveen.

DIP MLA Michelle McIlveenplaceholder image
DIP MLA Michelle McIlveen

"The Ulster Farmers’ Union, in its own briefing paper, has offered support only on the caveat that any scheme would be funded through additional resources. This Bill cannot give that assurance. There is no pot of new money sitting waiting for this scheme. In the current Department of Finance Draft Budget from 2026-2029/30, published by a Sinn Fein Minister, there is no mention of any additional funding to cover ANC payments. Any mandatory ANC payment would be prioritised over all other payments to farmers and will come from within the existing agriculture budget, meaning less support for other farm businesses through Farm Sustainability Payments and other schemes. This is ultimately a rob Peter to pay Paul Bill. That is neither fair nor sustainable. It is unjust and wrong to expect sheep and suckler cow farmers farming in Disadvantaged Areas throughout Northern Ireland to have a further top-slice to their Sustainable Agriculture Programme payments in order to support large farm owners in Severely Disadvantaged Areas.

"This Bill would also create further imbalance by linking ANC payments to inflation, even though no other part of the Sustainable Agriculture Programme is treated in that way.

"We also need to challenge the myth that farms in severely disadvantaged areas have been left without support since ANC ended in 2018. The evidence does not support that claim. There has been no significant relative change in livestock numbers or farmed area, while the move to land-based payments shifted more support towards disadvantaged land types,” the DUP MLA added.

"Farmers in these areas can also access help through schemes including the Beef Sustainability Package, Farming with Nature and the Environmental Farming Scheme.

"What Northern Ireland agriculture needs is not a return to regressive area-based payments with no link to productivity, but targeted support that improves efficiency, resilience and long-term sustainability. That is why we want to see practical measures such as a designated sheep scheme, helping family farms invest, improve animal health and welfare, and build for the next generation.”

News you can trust since 1963
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice