DAERA 'may need to recast the conditions' over carbon auditing after hearing AERA committee concerns

The “huge level of uncertainty and worry amongst the farming sector in relation to carbon auditing” and how DAERA “have handled it”, came under the microscope at the AERA committee.

AERA meeting in Stormont on November 26placeholder image
AERA meeting in Stormont on November 26

Addressing the committee, during a discussion on ‘Farm Sustainability Payment Scheme (Eligibility Etc) (Amendment) Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2026’, west Tyrone SDLP MLA Daniel McCrossan said: “I know the Department know there is a huge level of uncertainty and worry amongst the sector in relation to this issue and how the department have handled it, in relation to the muddled words like incentivise when there is an underlying threat if you do not co-operate your single farm payment will automatically be cut”.

"So I agree with others who said the language used is disappointing and actually feeds into the frustration that we are picking up on the ground in relation to DAERA doing this.

SDLP MLA Daniel McCrossan addressing AERA committeeplaceholder image
SDLP MLA Daniel McCrossan addressing AERA committee

"It just leads to a matter of ‘do as we say not as we do’ when it comes to these matters and I don’t believe that is acceptable.

“And I think when it comes to the comms piece which you reference in your presentation at the beginning, you really need to get to grips as to where the farming community are at.

“And that they are not foolish, they understand when they are not being told directly what is happening”.

Adding there is “concern about single farm payments and the disproportional impact it will have on the smaller family farm”, Mr McCrossan said: “So I want to cut through some of the noise here – you are saying the scheme is voluntary but if someone does not sign up to this their single farm payment is reduced?”

In response Richard Johnston – Director of Agriculture Policy Division Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs – said: “Yeah, so the decision is for the farm to participate and there is conditionality applied if it goes through the committee”.

Mr McCrossan probed further: “If they don’t participate, are they punished by a reduction in their single farm payment?”

Mr Johnston replied: “If conditionality is applied”.

Mr McCrossan said that DAERA seems to have included “a lot of stick and not a lot of carrot” which he said is “not the right approach by this Department and this is why confidence in the Department is at an all time low”.

He added that the process “is ok for a larger farming business, but not for a smaller family farm” and they are “really worried about this situation and will be more disproportionately affected because of the various administration hurdles in order to participate in this”.

Mr Johnston said: “Yes I suppose we have minimised the friction and the administration hurdles as far as possible.

"The LMC and the service provider will provide a lot of the work in so far as what needs to be done”.

He added: “We have minimised the amount of work for small family farms for what needs to be done and have brought forward training developed by the industry to help them implement it on the ground”.

The SDLP MLA added: “This is not a not a blanket opportunity for all farmers – and I am speaking about the significant number of small family farms that are worried about it.

“The Department in their communication need to be fair and recognise that our farmers provide the highest quality of food production anywhere in the world.

“They provide us with food security, they are vital to our food security and they are huge custodians of our environment and have been long before there were any conversations about the climate.

“So why doesn’t the Department give the farming sector the credit they deserve and actually put meaningful incentives in place to allow and enable them to put in place what you are trying to achieve, because this to me seems, ‘do as we say’ and that’s it”.

In response Mr Johnston said: “I suppose if you look at the work of the Department around SAP we are delivering £330 million to the sector and it is great to see it doing so well, we have had a number of years of record incomes in farming”.

AERA Chair Diana Armstrong then asked if the Department “would consider looking at the carbon footprint project again given what you have heard today?”

Mr Johnston said: “We will take it back to the Department and look at the options which depends on the decision the committee makes on conditionality.

"We may need to recast the conditions”.

And DUP MLA Gareth Wilson said after being told “how contentious the scheme is after we conveyed this to you, at what stage does that concern steer you in another direction?”

Mr Johnston said: "Everybody sitting around the table is making sure everything is going forward productively, we do listen and hear what is going on” and “we are aware of the strength of opinion”, but he “those decisions were ministerial”.

"We try to make sure it is easy to apply for”, he added and try to make “training as easy as possible for farmers”.

Adding there is “no plan to reduce livestock numbers”, he advised it is “a technological tool for better efficiency”.

"There may be suspicion about the motive”, he added, but “we are all paid by the public purse and we do our best to help farmers” though there has been “some clumsy language and a lack of communication at times, we can apologise for”.

"But I can guarantee everyone at the table has worked very hard to get these schemes through and are aimed to incentivise farmers”.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1963
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice