Fivemiletown cattle cull: Questions remain after Dr Martin Blake's report - 'I'm hearing time and time again who will be held accountable for this?'
AERA committee members today said they are hoping to get more answers around the Fivemiletown cattle cull report by Dr Martin Blake, on December 10.
Addressing the external Review of Fivemiletown Cattle Cull, AERA Committee Chair Diana Armstrong said “Dr Blake has stated that it was a lawful operation” adding she wanted to “verify the legal basis on which Dr Blake has made that determination on”.


"Is he legally qualified to make that determination?,” she said.
DUP committee member Michelle McIlveen added that “there's a difference of opinion in relation to the deprivation order and destruction order”.


She said they needed to get “some clarity in relation to that because that was clearly a decision”.
"While there was permission to destroy within the direction that came from the court, it was still a decision which was made by by the department, and I suppose none of us really are satisfied around the options that were looked at and how this could have been prevented,” said Ms McIlveen.
"I suppose primarily for me, I think I would like to have heard directly from Dr Blake".
She added that Dr Blake has received “public money” for his review and “I think he should actually be speaking to this committee in open session”.
Fellow DUP MLA Gareth Wilson said: “The amount of money that the review has cost the department, doesn't include departmental officials time.
"I think the figure mentioned was £18,000, but it is going to be vastly more than that when you factor in all the officials' time.
"I think based on the fact, Dr Blake's obviously been paid for this process and given the cost to the wider department, both financially and reputationally, I think it's vital that Dr Blake comes and allows us to ask the questions that we haven't got answers to yet”.
Meanwhile SDLP AERA committee member Daniel McCrossan said: “There is huge anger across the community in relation to this, and even since the publication of the review, there has been more and more questions raised that we feel have not been answered by the department appropriately.
"And I think that the question I'm hearing time and time again is who will be held accountable for this?
"And we also been hearing quite a number of experiences from the farming community about the approach taken by DAERA officials from various wings of the department when it comes to an issue on a particular farm, and the approach taken by the department in that regard, but here we have something that is quite serious, has angered a huge amount of people, and was handled so badly, embarrassingly, and in a way that should not be done by the department.
"So there are huge questions.
"I think Dr Blake really does need to come before the committee because I don't believe we're getting the answers to those questions from the minister or the officials”.
AERA Chair Diana Armstrong added “The permanent secretary has said that she takes full responsibility, but I'd like to ask the minister.
"The minister is over his department, is it the minister who takes responsibility as the final arbiter of the events at Five Mile Town.
"So really, that would be a question I'd be putting to him, as final responsibility over his department and the officials who work in it".
SDLP MLA Daniel McCrossan added: “The buck stops with the minister in charge of the department, but it also starts and stops with the accounting officer.
"So there are questions for both.
"The minister is denying all knowledge of the details or what was planned, but I just do not believe we're getting the full picture”.
“We’ll have an opportunity on December 10 to probe that further.”