Westminster will not be riding to the rescue Benn has warned
Executive ministers and MLAs were told this week they must make tough choices over spending plans for the coming financial year.
This warning came from the Secretary of State, Hilary Benn, and was intended to make clear that if decisions are ducked, Westminster will not be riding to the rescue. Politicians here are not good at trimming spending plans. Despite that reluctance, we have the worst health statistics in the UK; our roads are in a poor state and dodging potholes on rural roads is now impossible. Politicians like to be admired by voters and tough spending choices, which involve setting priorities and cutting back to afford what needs to be done, is not something they like to do. Yet that is exactly what the rest of us have to do, and we should expect nothing different from politicians. Pondering the Benn comment, one thought that came to mind was whether an independent Environment Protection Agency for Northern Ireland really needs to be a spending priority. This smacks of a vanity project and to date it is one that has an urban, metropolitan bias in its planning and no doubt operations if an EPA comes into existence. Tough choices begin with a simple question Is the decision really necessary or could the funds be better spent elsewhere. This appears the case over what would ultimately be a costly green quango, with no role or powers that could not be delivered through tweaked existing structures. An EPA will not solve problems like Lough Neagh it will instead talk about them and pick selectively who will be targeted for criticism; potentially it will ignore the problem for the environment from our crumbling infrastructure, which politicians have failed to address or fund. Executive members making decisions on spending priorities needs to accept that a new quango is not the way to solve environmental problems and instead direct limited resources to the areas that really will tackle the issues facing Northern Ireland, with its struggling health service and collapsing infrastructure. In a world of priorities there should be no time for grandiose vanity projects. On a European note, Keir Starmer has suggested he wants closer ties with the EU, setting out this week how that might work. He wants to go beyond a customs union to full membership of the EU single market. This suggests he has ideas around joining countries like Switzerland and Norway in the European Economic Area. That goes beyond a customs union, which Labour ruled out in its manifesto, but opinion polls suggest it would go down well with a majority of voters especially the “working families” Labour is committed to supporting. This is a long way from any referendum on re-joining the EU, but it would minimise further damage to the economy from Brexit on the terms delivered by Boris Johnson and his then supporters. This week also saw Starmer very much at the top table in the EU, when he was central, with France, in the “coalition of the willing” to support Ukraine now and in any peace settlement. This is an environment where Starmer feels comfortable and the UK involvement should remind the EU of its fundamental error in letting the UK, as globally accepted diplomats, leave the EU. This was in no small measure down to the EU and its member states failing to recognise the threat in assuming the leave option in the referendum would be easily defeated. Instead it left the then PM, David Cameron, isolated with no concessions to sugar coat his remain case. For agriculture Brexit has had no real impact. It has been a negative outcome, in that farmers have lost political influence and ended up with support structures less financially attractive than the CAP while facing more rather than less bureaucracy. The EU remains our biggest export market for food and the UK the biggest market for the EU. All Brexit has done is add red tape and costs, which in a competitive market can only reduce margins. At the same time it has denied the UK access to overseas markets where it had reduced or tariff free access to as an EU member states although with the Mercosur deal with South America after more than 20 years that might be a bullet worth dodging for now. Replacement post Brexit trade deals, for example with the southern hemisphere, have offered little for farmers in terms of export potential, but have left farmers here with less protection against imports than those in the EU. For once, the Starmer approach might prove a vote winner.